The American Message Foundation
Home / Studies / Messaging Guide

How to Talk About Values

Do progressives (broadly defined, from center to left) have an affirmative message? Should they tack to the center or the left? These are empirical questions, which require empirical answers. So we tested them. Over 2000 voters rated progressive and right-wing messages across over a dozen issues (0-100 scale).

2000+voters rated messages
89progressive messages tested
12 of 12perennial issues won
+22average advantage

Messaging Guide

Results

Progressives did not have an affirmative message. They had 89. The messages beat right-wing language on all 12 perennial issues and some of the most difficult – e.g., trans – by an average of +22.

How? They were written in emotionally evocative, values-based, everyday language.

Emotionally evocative

People vote with their hearts and justify with their heads. Messages that make people feel something are the ones that stick.

Values-based

Leaders should tack to their values, not to the left or the center. Effective messages offer a choice between values systems.

Everyday language

No jargon and no white papers. Plain words that sound like a person talking to a neighbor.

Takeaway

Should progressive leaders tack to the left or center?

Neither. They should tack to their values.

Progressive messages are effective when they offer a choice between values systems. Progressives need to get comfortable with the language of values so they can articulate what guides their leadership.

Message Discipline

Think jazz.

Traditional talking points make leaders sound scripted. Message discipline means playing from the same songbook while improvising in your own voice.

You can persuade people by lying well or by telling the truth well. We believe in democracy, science, and accountability, so we have truth on our side.

Free Messaging Guide

How to Talk About Values

Empirically tested messaging on every major issue, ready to use. Plagiarize liberally.

Read the Memo

Members of the public are licensed to use the messages for any non-commercial purpose.

The Offer

Choose your values. Say them out loud.

Progressive messages win when they present a clear choice between two value systems. Our tables give leaders the exact words.

"Neither left nor center. Tack to your values."

Tables

Tested messages, by issue

The tables in this guide provide empirically tested messaging anyone can use, on every major issue. So plagiarize – liberally.

Issue name (placeholder)

PLACEHOLDER – message table to be supplied by AMF. Columns: Message, Type, Average rating (0-100).

©The American Message Foundation. Members of the public are licensed to use the messages for any non-commercial purpose.

Methodology

Methods

Over 2000 voters rated progressive and right-wing messages across over a dozen issues on a 0-100 scale.

[PLACEHOLDER – sample composition, field dates, how messages were written and assigned, margin of error, and any weighting to be supplied by AMF.]

Subscribe to our messaging guides

Design mock